« Back To Best of Food & Drink

Best Pizza Place

Thirsty Pagan

Thirsty Pagan pizzas are made to order using Wisconsin cheese, the finest meats and fresh cut veggies. Specialty pizzas range in price from $15 to just under $30. Steve Knauss, owner, is not only a stand-up guy, he’s a stand-up comedian. Eat some pizza, enjoy one of their microbrews and ask Steve for a joke.

2nd Place: Vintage Italian Pizza.

3rd Place: Sammy’s by two measly little votes.