Miata, Beetle Cabrio Differ in Winter Approach

John Gilbert

 

MX-5 Miata can be bought with 18 percent more power, retractable hardtop for warm security. Photo credit: John Gilbert
MX-5 Miata can be bought with 18 percent more power, retractable hardtop for warm security. Photo credit: John Gilbert

 

We had been counting on the chance to thoroughly test out Hyundai Kona New Car Pick of the Year in the severe cold this past week — and trust me, we have done that — but we can’t pass up the chance to inject a little priceless irony into our January road tests on the North Shore of Lake Superior.
I got the chance to try out a pair of cars that are much better suited to summertime warmth, but they still made worthy chariots for January and its waybelow-zero conditions.
They are the 2019 Mazda MX-5, better known as the Miata, which is a convertible, but also has a new “targa” model with a power hardtop that drops into the trunk area when you want top-down driving. I believe that, and you’ll excuse me if I passed up my wife, Joan, and her suggestion that I could bundle up in layers of fleece and down and drive past her while she took my picture. No. I’m surprised she didn’t agree to do the air-conditioned driving while I shot the photos.

The test part is how the hardtop works on the traditional convertible roadster.
The other vehicle that closely followed the Miata MX-5 was the 2019 Volkswagen Beetle Convertible. The Beetle is heading for its last roundup, as VW has declared it will stop making the car after the current generation runs out. So I got the chance to drive the soft-top Beetle convertible
Both of these cars are obviously summertime specialties, but the both have their attraction for derivers of all ages and sizes.

 

MX-5 Miata retains sporty look and hardtop adds exotic touring image.  Photo credit: John Gilbert
MX-5 Miata retains sporty look and hardtop adds exotic touring image. Photo credit: John Gilbert
Always striking in silhouette, Miata still must add the caution of rear-drive  on icy road conditions. Photo credit: John Gilbert
Always striking in silhouette, Miata still must add the caution of rear-drive on icy road conditions. Photo credit: John Gilbert

 

First, the MX-5

The biggest winter challenge for the MX-5, which 95 percent of the world’s drivers continue to call the Miata, by my humble estimation, has several enhancements for 2019, including a power-boost to the engine, which is now a 2.0-liter with nearly 20 percent more horsepower, at 181, and 151 foot-pounds of torque.

That makes a big difference in a light and agile roadster, and the larger engine does allow you to put the car through more paces, quicker.
But the biggest story of the test car, which costs up in the middle-$30,000 range, is the roof. A lot of companies have tried hideaway-hardtops with varied success. Some look bulbous when the top is up, others not so much. But the roof on the Miata is a jewel, with strongly contoured lines and grooves that make it look like a fixed hardtop with a racey slope as it comes down to blend into the trunk.

It works very well to insulate the driver and passenger from the cold, and the heater and other features work efficiently to keep you cozy and secure.
Of course, the uncompromising problem with driving a Miata in Minnesota wintertime is that its peppy little front-mounted engine sends its power to the rear — a method that old-time purists claim is the way a true performance car should be. I disagree, having proven many times that a well-engineered front-engine/front-wheel-drive car can handle as well as any rear-drive sports car, it just isn’t so insistent on spinning out. With rear drive, even with snow tires, the rears spin and try to overtake the powerless front end.

So if you want to drive a Miata in winter and prove how warm you can stay with the roof up and fixed in place, you’ll enjoy the warmth and security, but you’ll still want to be very careful if you encounter any ice or hills. Or, in Duluth, Minnesota — both.
A refined interior also is pleasant, and the test car came with a 6-speed stick shift, which helped it get around after a light snowstorm. I was late for an appointment, however, because our driveway is pretty level, and then tilts up just slightly over the last 50 feet to the main rural road passing our house. I tried slowly to creep up that final slope, but the ice under the snow caused me to spin. I tried again, backing up each time to get something of a run at it. All in all, it took about 15 minutes before I got it just right and made it onto the road.

So the nice interior, the spunky engine, the crisp-shifting transmission and the razor-sharp handling, plus the hardtop, make the new Miata worth $35,000, but be very, very careful if you drive it on wintry roads.

 

Beetle’s iconic silhouette works with Cabrio and Lake Superior sunrise at  20 below. Photo credit: John Gilbert
Beetle’s iconic silhouette works with Cabrio and Lake Superior sunrise at 20 below. Photo credit: John Gilbert
Tight fit of fabric roof makes the VW Beetle secure and warm even when  temperature plunges, and FWD works on ice. Photo credit: John Gilbert
Tight fit of fabric roof makes the VW Beetle secure and warm even when temperature plunges, and FWD works on ice. Photo credit: John Gilbert
Quilted seats are comfortable and firmly supportive -- with great headroom.  Photo credit: John Gilbert
Quilted seats are comfortable and firmly supportive - with great headroom. Photo credit: John Gilbert
If Beetle is going to disappear, its familiar shape will be missed by avid drivers.  Photo credit: John Gilbert
If Beetle is going to disappear, its familiar shape will be missed by avid drivers. Photo credit: John Gilbert

VW Beetle Convertible

My mother bought a new Beetle in 1960, and I learned a lot about driving in that car, among other things. In those days, of course, the Beetle was the nickname for the rounded little vehicle with its flat-opposed rear-mounted/rear-drive 4-cylinder engine. That car had great traction for hills, with the weight of the engine over the drive wheels, although in a few icy situations if you over-corrected you might get the rear end to swing around like a pendulum, and spinouts were both surprising and exciting.

When Volkswagen brought back the Beetle in its most recent incarnations, it wisely modernized the car to essentially become a Golf with a Beetle body. The Golf has front-engine/front-wheel-drive, and is legendary as an all-weather performer with its various hot little engines.
The cabriolet, or cabrio, is the convertible version, and the “ragtop” is extremely tight and precise fitting. You do hear a bit more road noise than in a full-roofed car, but you don’t feel particularly cold or uncomfortable because of the roof’s lack of solidness. The roofline of the Beetle Cabrio is particularly appealing, the way it slopes back and blends in perfectly.

The test car, stubbornly trying to stay under $30,000, is worth buying if you ever liked Beeltes, just for the collectors who will one day be seeking them. If VW quits making them, or bringing them to the U.S., they will probably be more valuable than they are new.
Buried under a foot-deep snowstorm, I went out and popped the door open, climbed aboard, and hit the push-button starter, and even though it had been idle for two days, it fired up instantly. I drove it for a short dash just so i could line it up with the interesting background of the winter sky over Lake Superior, when the temperature was 15-below actual and wind-chill somewhere below that.

A year ago, you could get the Beetle Turbo, which was basically a GTI in Beetle style. VW has tried other models, and now it is pretty basic, with a 2.0-liter turbo that has 174 horsepower and 184 foot-pounds of torque. That puts the Beetle Cabrio in pretty swift company, and its suspension is sufficient to allow you to zip around curves and cloverleafs with ease, even if it isn’t an outright sporty car.

The Beetle’s most recent style arched the roofline a bit farther back to provide more headroom in the rear, and that style remains, even with the Cabrio. I’m not sure how many adult friends you can coax to climb into the rear seats, especially when the temperature is bone-chilling cold. But wait until a nice June afternoon, when the sun is still high and the temperature is in the high 70s, and you drop the top and ask friends if they’d like to go for a ride, and you might need to accept bids.

The base Beetle starts at around $21,000, and you can add features to boost that price. Obviously,. going to the Cabrio boosts it highest, but the above-mentioned Miata is probably one of the few mainstream convertibles you can find, and that’s a 2-seater.
The seats in the Beetle are quilted and fit over well-contoured front buckets, which provide more support and comfort than any VW seat this side of a GTI that I can recall. The new Golf is impressive, and the new Beetle Cabrio is soon to become the “old” Beetle. So get one while you can, and be sure it will give you many miles of endurance and over-30-mpg economy.